王妃卡特贏了官司,權力?法律?
The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have won their first legal battle in an attempt to block further publication of photos of the Duchess sunbathing topless while on vacation in France.
劍橋公爵和公爵夫人在試圖阻止公爵夫人在法國度假時赤裸上身曬日光浴的照片進一步刊登，他們已經贏得了首個法律官司。The photos must not be published again, a French court ruled Tuesday, according to the BBC. And Closer magazine, which was the first to obtain and print them, was ordered to give the originals to the couple within 24 hours.
據英國廣播公司報導：法國法院週二裁定，照片不得再次刊登。首次獲得並刊登照片的《CLoser》雜誌被命令將底片在24小時內歸還皇室夫婦。A royal source said, "They welcome the injunction that's been granted. They always believed the law was broken and that they were entitled to their privacy."
據王室消息人士說，“他們對已批准的這項禁令表示欣然接受。他們始終相信（裸照事件中）法律被打破了，同時他們應享有隱私權。”
The ruling applies only to France. The Irish Daily Star and the Italian magazine Chi have already republished the photos – the latter in a 26-page section on Monday.
這項裁決只適用於法國。愛爾蘭每日星報和意大利雜誌《Chi》已經刊登了照片——後者在週一製作了一個26頁的特刊。British newspapers, so far, have refrained from printing the photos. But on Monday in Dublin, the publishers of the Irish Daily Star released the following statement: "Independent Star Limited has suspended editor Michael O'Kane, pending an investigation into the circumstances that led to the Irish Daily Star re-publishing pages from the French magazine Closer, which contained images of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge."
英國報紙到目前爲止被限制刊登這些照片。但週一在都柏林，愛爾蘭每日星報的出版商發表了以下聲明：“獨立之星有限公司已暫停編輯邁克爾•奧凱恩的職務，正在調查愛爾蘭每日星報刊登法國雜誌 《Closer》 有關劍橋公爵和公爵夫人照片的事件。The statement went on to say: "Independent Star Ltd. has no further comment pending conclusion of the joint investigation by the newspaper's shareholders."
聲明接着說：“在股東聯合調查結束之前，獨立之星公司還沒有進一步的結論。”William and Kate, though keeping a brave face during the embarrassing episode while on a tour of Asia, have also filed a criminal complaint against Closer and will be seeking damages, a spokesperson for Clarence House said on Monday.
克拉倫斯宮的發言人週一表示：威廉和凱特在這段尷尬時期雖然一直勇敢面對，但在亞洲之旅時已經對《Closer》雜誌提起了民事訴訟並將尋求賠償。French attorney Vincent Tolédano, a specialist in media law tells PEOPLE, "Closer" cannot publish these images any longer. Now it is up to the criminal investigation to try and determine who the photographer is. In court, Closer maintained they didn't own the rights to the images, and now it is up to the police ... to investigate and determine the particulars.
媒體法律專家即法國律師Vincent Tolédano告訴《People》說：“ 《Closer》不能再刊登這些照片。現在正根據刑事調查試圖確定攝影師是誰。在法庭上，《Closer》堅持說他們沒有擁有這些照片的權利，現在則是要靠警方...去調查和確定詳情。”He added, "There are freedom of press and protection of sources issues in play now."
他補充說：“現在事件中涉及媒體的自由以及保護消息來源者的問題。”
